Build a panel of virtual AI experts to review ideas and projects

Workflow: Evaluation
Build a panel of virtual AI experts to review ideas and projects

1. Describe the task

Good reviews need the right expert at the right moment: a devil’s advocate, a domain specialist, someone who knows your business practices, a presentation coach. Those people are scarce, and a generic AI review sounds the same for every idea.

Hand the reviews to Prism. Build your experts once, as elements: create an element type for experts and write each persona into it, with its role, what to look for, tone and the format of the answer. Then name one or more experts in a prompt, together with the idea, project or technology they should work on. Each expert reviews from its own angle, and Prism brings the results together.

Example prompt:
Use our experts Devil’s Advocate, Business Practice Advisor and Presentation Coach on this idea. Each should review it from their own perspective. Then agree on the three most important improvements and propose a revised description.

2. Give context

Required inputs

  • An element type for experts (for example "Virtual Experts"), with each persona written into a text field.
  • The element the experts should work on, open on screen or named in the prompt.
  • A Master Context, so the experts judge against your strategy.

3. What ITONICS AI creates

Example output:

Review of the idea “Shared tool pool across plants” by three virtual experts, each following its own instructions, then three improvements they agree on and a revised description.

Expert

Main point

Devil's Advocate

Most damaging objection: many fixtures are part-specific or owned by the car maker, so they can’t move between plants without consent. If most idle tools are like this, the idea fails.

Business Practice Advisor

The text describes a symptom, idle tools, not a root cause. Only one plant has been observed, and the 20 to 30% saving has no baseline. First question: what share of the tools are generic, and which overlap between plants?

Presentation Coach

The ask is buried and hedged. Open with one concrete fact about idle tools and close with a specific pilot request.

Recommended improvements: replace the guess with a baseline from Zaragoza and at least one more plant; limit the pilot to generic fixtures and measuring gauges, excluding customer-owned and part-specific tools; and present a net case with a clear ask.

Follow-up prompts:

Example prompt:
Ask the Presentation Coach to turn the revised idea into a five-slide pitch.
Example prompt:
Write the revised description into the idea’s empty fields.
Example prompt:
Have the Devil’s Advocate review the revised version again.

More AI use cases

The modular platform for R&D, strategy & innovation teams