Foresight in the energy sector: lessons from 21 expert interviews

Nathalie FrankeBy Nathalie Franke
foresight-in-the-energy-sector-1920x450

I’ve done a qualitative study into more effective foresight frameworks for the energy sector. This was part of my master’s thesis while a werkstudentin at an electricity transmission grid operator. I wanted to see how we could integrate the ITONICS platform, and foresight and trend management more broadly, into the organization. My research ran in parallel with the ITONICS proof of concept, so while I was still asking questions, some answers were already needed for practical decisions.

Having a tool and actually using it are two different things

It was not a question about which tool we needed. The question became: How do we actually bring foresight and trend management into an organization? From the beginning, I knew that the answer had to be scientifically grounded, organizationally realistic and, ultimately, accepted by the people who would work with it.

Participation is essential if foresight is meant to become more than a concept on paper. A tool can be introduced more easily than a new way of thinking about the future.

We had to bring two different worlds together. On one side there’s foresight, trend management, strategy, innovation and digitalization. On the other side there is organizational reality: structures, responsibilities, limited resources, existing processes, decision-making pathways, motivation and, most importantly, people.

A theoretically perfect process has little value if nobody participates in it. But a popular process is not automatically a good foresight process either. My challenge was therefore to move from literature to lived reality, and from a concept to something that could actually work within an organization.

Hidden experts

For the empirical part of my research, I conducted 21 expert interviews. I wanted internal and external perspectives, foresight practitioners but also specialists, leaders and people who understood how the organization works.

This was especially important in a highly technical environment. A great deal of innovation-relevant knowledge sits with people who may never describe themselves as foresight professionals. They understand technologies, supervise studies, recognize needs in their fields or know which organizational barriers have to be overcome before an idea can move forward. In that sense, involving them in the research was already a first step towards the kind of participation the later process was supposed to enable.

I analyzed all the interviews in MAXQDA using Kuckartz's qualitative content analysis. The conversations went in different directions depending on who I was speaking with, and the more interviews I did, the less linear the picture became. But every additional perspective gave me another opportunity to question an assumption I had made before.

When one process was no longer enough

More themes popped up in the interviews. Leadership buy-in and change management became increasingly relevant. Questions of measurement came up, such as whether qualitative value could be supported by quantitative KPIs. And regulatory requirements, the political environment, rhythms for signal scanning, interfaces between departments and organizational culture all had to be considered.

At some point, I realized that what I had originally imagined, one trend management process within a broader foresight context, was no longer enough. I had to let go of my original solution without letting go of my research question. Organizational feasibility had been part of the ambition from the beginning, so the result had to fit reality.

What eventually emerged was a three-layer approach:

  1. A set of design principles. They describe, at the most general level, what should be considered when foresight and trend management processes are designed. This level helped preserve the scientific transferability of the findings.
  2. An organizational foresight framework. Here, questions around governance, knowledge architecture, evaluation architecture, methodologies, digital infrastructure, performance measurement and cultural integration became relevant. Before a process can work, the organization needs the structures that allow it to take hold.
  3. Only then did I arrive at the detailed trend management process. Here, the questions became very tangible: Who does what, and when? What information needs to be handed over? Which artifacts are created? Where can technology and AI provide support? And where does human judgment remain essential?

So what began as the search for a process ended up moving from principles to a framework, from a framework to a process and, hopefully, from a process to a routine. Foresight only becomes part of an organization when responsibilities, platforms and governance no longer need to be re-explained every time.

Nathalie on closing the Impact Gap, and how trends are rated at a grid operator

What does future-readiness actually mean?

In the electricity sector, and particularly in a regulated environment, the logic is different from that of many conventional companies. The primary goal is not simply to enter new markets or maximize growth. Market potential can still be relevant, but system relevance and security of supply are central. For many companies, foresight may ask where the next market is. In our context, the more important question may be what could become relevant to the system for which we carry responsibility.

This means keeping trends on the radar and reducing blind spots as far as possible. The energy transition, climate change, artificial intelligence and regulatory developments all influence this environment. Planning is often very long-term, while technological and political developments can move quickly. So the aim is not to predict one exact future, but to build enough flexibility into research, projects and organizational structures to be able to react when things change.

The room to maneuver in a regulated environment can be relatively narrow, but that does not mean that future-oriented thinking should also be narrow. It means thinking far enough ahead within clear boundaries. Energy is not a nice-to-have. That is part of what makes future-oriented work in this field so demanding, but also so interesting.

Where automation helps

Signal scanning produces a quantity of information that no individual foresight or trend manager can process manually. Technology can help condense that information, identify clusters and show where signals are accumulating. Regular automated scanning also helps an organization stay up to date when markets, technologies, regulation or the wider environment are changing.

I do not see this as replacing people with AI. Technology can support scanning, clustering, monitoring and preparation, and it can broaden the field of view. People still need to understand what the information means, assess its relevance and decide how to respond.

Nathalie on keeping people in charge of decisions, and why a shared source of truth matters

See, understand, act

After months of reading, listening, discussing and writing, I do not want these insights to remain pages in a thesis. I want to see what happens when we give them life, and when something that was once mentioned in an interview eventually feeds into an initiative, a project or a better decision.

For me, foresight comes down to seeing, understanding and acting. The future will probably never follow the perfect process diagram. But we can create better conditions today to recognize change and respond when it arrives.

More insights on Strategy